I have this a 3 doe removing only because I don’t want it too and it doesn’t come off unless Your using a good makeup remover which is basically what we want it to do right ! FabboIt provides just enough depth and I think it curls my lashes a bit. I was pleased.Does not remove easily. But lashes are longer and fuller best mascara I have foundHave used for yearsThis brand never disappoints. My "going out" mascara, Always goes on easily, color is on point. Never smudges, smears or runs. Definitely cry-proof! My old stand-by that I will love forever.I didn't think this was any better than the grocery store brands...As a matter of fact it made my eyes itch after it was on for a while... I wouldn't buy it again because of cost and effectiveness.It is not easy to remove from lashes. It made my lashes to stiff. I bought 2 of them this year. I am not using it now.Love this mascara, goes on great and wears all day!