I have very straight lashes, so I must use waterproof mascara to hold a curl. This mascara causes my lashes to flatten out, so that is my only complaint. Otherwise, this is a great mascara. Very black and shiny, no flaking or smudging, I love the metal wand applicator, equal to the more expensive Hourglass version. Removed easily with a makeup remover suitable for waterproof mascara. I wish the formula was not as wet so as to keep the curl in my lashes.I like this more for my lower lashes than my upper ones. However, the formula is great. It does not flake, at least not that I have noticed. I wish the dips in the metal were a little deeper to individualize each lash more. Overall I would give this an 8.5/10. I will be buying this item again.I recently tried the pink version of Dermalogy’s mascara and liked it so well I decided to try this one too.This works as well as the pink version adding color to the lashes but it adds volume also.I put this mascara on Amazon’s ‘subscribe and save’. But unfortunately, I see they raised their prices substantially since I purchased. It is now $10 more for this mascara, the one in the pink tube and the price of refills has also increased.While I really like the mascara, I think the price is way over the top. It was already expensive prior to the price increase. For that reason I will have to cancel my ‘subscribe and save’ and I won’t be reordering. I hope they reconsider the price because it truly is a nice mascara.This did not work for me as well as it did for the influencers I saw use it, but I have short lashes that easily clump together. I need a wand with bristles. It does feel luxurious. It also didn’t last long with my oily lids.I really bought this mascara for the wand; I have used something similar in the past to comb out my lashes without using those terrifying spiky metal combs. But, I actually really enjoy this mascara! My one complaint (and it’s only a complaint when it comes to the end of the day) is that this mascara is really different to come off, but that means it stays in place all day! I have used micellar water, oil based makeup removers, makeup removing balms, and I STILL couldn’t get it all the way off. The best thing to do is to wet your face, try to remove as much as you can, then use a warm washcloth pressed gently on the eyelids to help loosen it up. Somehow this method works better than the makeup removers. I probably won’t buy it again, but that’s because I just wanted the wand! The wand is great!I like the applicator of this mascara. It is a little different and difficult to remove when taking off your makeup at the end if the day. I would suggest an oil cleanser to remove.Love it but overpriced. Works just the same as normal mascara. Not really worth the costloves this mascara, my lashes are super short and this mascara just makes them look so long only downside is it is difficult to remove the mascara and often times when removing i pull out my lashes棒タイプなので上やしたにマスカラが付きにくくて普通に使いやすいですʚ･֊･ɞ⸒⸒